A Dutch court has handed Jaguar Land Rover one of the most sweeping design-rights victories seen in the European auto industry in years. The BYD Defender Dutch court ruling comes as BYD expands in Europe. It stops that expansion cold, at least on the continent.
The District Court of The Hague issued a ruling in preliminary relief finding that BYD’s Fangchengbao Ti7 infringes Jaguar Land Rover’s registered Community Design for the Defender. That registered design is formally catalogued as Uniemodel 1. The court ordered an EU-wide injunction. The order covers import, sale and advertising of the Ti7 across all 27 European Union member states. The court backed the injunction with a dwangsom, a Dutch legal mechanism that imposes heavy daily financial penalties for each day BYD violates the order. The court proceedings were not without controversy: Dutch bailiffs had previously raided BYD offices, and the court later ordered JLR to destroy digital documents seized in excess of its legal authority. BYD has stated it is appealing the ruling.
For European car buyers and dealerships, the injunction requires the covered BYD entities to stop infringement within one week of service, with the court threatening heavy daily fines. The Dutch court held it lacked jurisdiction over BYD UK; it did not determine the wider UK legal position.
The Post-Brexit Jurisdiction Loophole and Appeal Plans
The court’s decision rested on a detailed visual comparison. Judges examined the court’s cited combination of rounded shoulders and corners, window line, C-pillar panel, proportions and overall silhouette. The court found the similarities too close to be coincidental. Under EU law, a registered Community Design gives its holder protection across all member states simultaneously. That is how a single Dutch ruling carries legal force in Paris, Berlin and Warsaw. BYD is now navigating appeal proceedings while its European distribution network sits effectively frozen. The appeal process will take time, and the preliminary injunction remains in force until a higher court rules otherwise. The daily financial penalties mean every week of delay is expensive. Here the post-Brexit legal landscape creates a stark divide. When the United Kingdom left the European Union, it also exited the EU Community Design framework. The injunction cannot travel across the Channel. The Dutch court held it lacked jurisdiction over BYD UK; it did not determine the wider UK legal position. This matters commercially. The plug-in hybrid Ti7 sits squarely in the premium SUV segment where BYD has been targeting growth, as documented in reporting on BYD’s European sales growth. The PHEV market in Europe remains sizeable for reducing fleet emissions even under regulatory pressure, and losing access to 27 markets at once is a serious blow to any manufacturer’s decarbonisation ambitions. JLR’s own trajectory in this space is tracked in coverage of Jaguar’s electric model roadmap.
JLR obtained an EU-wide injunction against the covered BYD entities, but the Dutch court held it lacked jurisdiction over BYD UK; it did not determine the wider UK legal position.
The District Court of The Hague banned BYD from selling its Ti7 SUV across the European Union after ruling that its exterior styling infringed Jaguar Land Rover’s registered design rights for the Defender. The court pointed to similarities in the vehicle’s rounded shoulders and corners, window line, C-pillar panel, proportions and overall silhouette.
BYD’s appeal will be one of the most watched cases in automotive design law this decade. The outcome will define how much creative protection legacy brands can claim over a silhouette.