Unmasking the Inefficiencies of Plastic Bag Recycling Drop-Off Directories in US

December 6, 2023
2 mins read
Plastic Recycling
The Secret Life of Plastic Recycling

The recent shutdown of the national online recycling directory for plastic bags and plastic films, once accessible at BagandFilmRecycling.org, raises significant questions about the reality of plastic recycling in the United States. This closure, occurring after two decades of operation, follows an ABC News investigation revealing troubling truths about plastic recycling processes.

Screenshot of BagandFilmRecycling.org’s drop-off directory page before the site was taken offline.

The Film Drop-Off Directory was a resource guiding the public to over 18,000 store drop-off locations for recycling used plastic bags and film. However, recent developments have brought to light the inefficiencies and false promises surrounding these recycling practices. Nina Bellucci Butler, CEO of Stina Inc., which managed the directory, expressed disillusionment with the industry’s lack of commitment to maintaining credible recycling data. “Continuing to offer a resource without real commitment from the industry and seeing how many organizations were willing to backfill without any integrity of how they are going to maintain data, I just couldn’t be a part of it anymore,” Butler said. This statement underscores a broader issue in the recycling industry: the gap between perception and reality.

Assembled bundles of recyclable plastic bags, each containing a metal tracking device super glued inside, then wrapped in several layers of bags, to determine if they are recycled.

Similar Posts


The directory’s closure is attributed partly to funding challenges in maintaining credible information. However, Butler also points to a broader problem: the illusion of effective recycling. She highlights the economic imbalance where producing virgin plastic is cheaper than recycling, creating a supply and demand issue. Despite initial funding by the American Chemistry Council (ACC) and endorsements from organizations like the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), the directory struggled to sustain itself financially and ethically.

Some of the plastic bag trackers placed in store recycling bins later pinged from incinerators, with one registering from the Wheelabrator facility in Peekskill, New York.

An investigative effort by ABC News further exposed these flaws. The news outlet, using metal tracking devices hidden in bundles of recyclable plastic bags, discovered that many bags deposited at Walmart and Target stores, listed in the directory, ended up in landfills, incinerators, or other non-recycling facilities. Out of 46 trackers, only four were traced to facilities involved in plastic bag recycling. This revelation prompted Stina Inc. to remove all Walmart and Target locations from their list, questioning the integrity of their recycling claims.

Drop-off bin in New Jersey to recycle plastic bags.

The investigation’s findings reflect a concerning trend of greenwashing, where companies and organizations market themselves as environmentally friendly while doing little to support these claims. Butler acknowledges the role of the ABC News investigation in highlighting these issues, but suggests that it’s part of a larger problem of misleading environmental progress.

In response, both Walmart and Target have issued statements emphasizing their commitment to reducing plastic waste and improving recycling processes. However, their refusal to participate in interviews or provide transparency on their recycling practices raises doubts about their actual contributions to environmental sustainability.

The wider implications of this issue extend beyond the directory’s closure. The ACC’s WRAP program, which initially funded the directory, has also gone offline. The EPA, which had linked to the now-defunct WRAP website, has updated its webpages following ABC News’ notification of the closure.

This development calls for a critical reassessment of the plastic recycling industry. It reveals the need for more transparent, credible, and effective recycling practices and challenges the prevailing narratives of environmental responsibility in corporate America. As consumers and citizens, it’s essential to scrutinize the claims made by corporations and organizations about their environmental practices and demand greater accountability and transparency in recycling and waste management processes.

Tejal Somvanshi

Meet Tejal Somvanshi, a soulful wanderer and a staunch wellness advocate, who elegantly navigates through the enchanting domains of Fashion and Beauty with a natural panache. Her journey, vividly painted with hues from a vibrant past in the media production world, empowers her to carve out stories that slice through the cacophony, where brands morph into characters and marketing gimmicks evolve into intriguing plot twists. To Tejal, travel is not merely an activity; it unfolds as a chapter brimming with adventures and serendipitous tales, while health is not just a regimen but a steadfast companion in her everyday epic. In the realms of fashion and beauty, she discovers her muse, weaving a narrative where each style narrates a story, and every beauty trend sparks a dialogue. Tejal seamlessly melds the spontaneous spirit of the media industry with the eloquent prose of a storyteller, crafting tales as vibrant and dynamic as the industry she thrives in.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Electreon Unveils the World's First Commercial Wireless Charging Terminal for Buses in Israel
Previous Story

Electreon Debuts Israel’s First Wireless E-Bus Charging Terminal: A Glimpse into Future Urban Transit

LOI Airbus and Space Compass-Zephyr. Source: Airbus
Next Story

AALTO’s Zephyr: Solar-Powered Flights Set New Standards in Rural Connectivity

Latest from News

Don't Miss

Artist Impression of Trash on Galapagos Islands.

Galápagos Crisis: How 99% of Island’s Recyclable Waste Comes from Overseas Ships

According to the environmental organization Ecoagents, crew members